Luton Town’s sad demise leaves a string of haunting questions
The sky is still black and a patina of dew sits on the cars as the first coaches trundle out of Hertfordshire. The destination is Middlesbrough – a 400-mile round trip and a fourth straight defeat on the road await Luton Town’s supporters.
The Championship is supposedly plagued with “yo-yo” clubs, robbing the league of its competitive edge on their way to a quickfire escape back to the Premier League. But what of those who go the other way, falling off the radar and into the void?
When Luton were relegated in May, Rob Edwards conceded that the mission to keep them up had proved “the impossible job”. On their way to an inevitability – made certain by an injury crisis decimating an already thin squad – they had surprised plenty of people: thumping Brighton, holding Liverpool and running Manchester United, Arsenal and Manchester City close.
That made the months that followed all the more bewildering. Luton return from the international break 21st in the table, kept afloat from the relegation zone by goals scored. They are 17th in the table for shots on goal and only newly-promoted Portsmouth have shipped more at the other end.
Edwards’ reign looked to have ended at the Riverside, the same ground where it began on an optimistic December afternoon two years ago, the mist clearing from the Qatar World Cup as English football’s wheels began to turn again. This time, jeered by his own fans, a cursory wave at the away end looked distinctively like a goodbye. He insisted he would not be sticking around if he was going to become a “divisive figure”.
Perhaps it is the hangover of the Premier League’s altitude that has made their descent from the mountain so stark, but some players are “waiting for the cable car to take them back up again, rather than fight their way back to the top of it”.
That is the view of Kevin Harper of the Luton Town Supporters’ Trust, who believes Edwards cannot bear the ultimate burden of responsibility for everything that has gone so horribly wrong.
“Ultimately, when players cross the white line, they have a duty to themselves to perform to the best of their ability,” Harper tells i. “Certainly [in the 5-1 defeat to Middlesbrough] very, very few could look in the mirror and say they’ve done that.
“Rob’s one of those managers that when everything’s going well he takes none of the credit, but when it’s all going wrong he takes all of the criticism. If the good times are the players, then the bad times can be the players’ fault as well. You win as a team, you lose as a team and the manager’s part of both.”
The process to identify Edwards as Nathan Jones’s successor was extensive, the 41-year-old hand-picked using data analysis in the same way players are recruited. That confirmed to CEO Gary Sweet that he was the right fit.
How Luton’s summer unfolded
Yet whoever was in charge would have struggled to withstand the departures of Ross Barkley – so impressive last season that talk of a shock England recall was mooted – as well as Chiedozie Ogbene, Ryan Giles and Andros Townsend. Barkley’s fee was undisclosed, but it was understood to be in the region of just £5m.
That is not to say the summer after relegation was totally without hope. At £10m, Mark McGuinness, a long-term centre-back target, was the most expensive arrival from Cardiff.
Luton kept hold of Manchester United academy product Teden Mengi when he looked destined to join Torino; he has since been rewarded with another England U21 call-up. In that light, it is easy to see why Edwards was not convinced he needed another defender. As a result, the move for Nathan Ngoy from Standard Liege collapsed.
Victor Moses was a free agent and had not been prolific in Russia, Italy or Turkey. Even if he had, it did not get to the crux of the problem in midfield, with too many ball-players and too few willing to put the proverbial boot in.
Whether the board did enough, or whether they took for granted that this was a squad that was ready to compete, is the question that will haunt them should they not turn around the latest in a string of poor starts.
“When we started the Premier League season, the accusation that was thrown at us was that we were recruiting for a relegation to the Championship,” Harper says.
“As the season went along, that narrative changed because of the performances that were taking place. Had it not been for injuries we might have stayed in the Premier League. So I can understand why the board thought they had a squad that was good enough.
“They’ll have known they were losing Ross Barkley from a fairly early stage. I’m sure they tried to replace him but they haven’t got anywhere near the guy who will take the ball in the centre of the park to drive us up the pitch with quality, and that’s where we’re lacking. Barkley was 90 per cent of our play, everything went through him, it literally was ‘give it to Barkley and let him do his thing’ at times.”
The end of the line?
Everything is caveated by the new stadium – due to open in 2027 – and the financial constraints that loom in the background as a result.
It is telling then that should Edwards leave Kenilworth Road, he will do so with reputation largely intact, the mastermind behind the club’s greatest day in four decades at Wembley 18 months ago. What will make or break his tenure now is whether he is willing to abandon his back three, a system that has seen Alfie Doughty thrive but which has also left them painfully exposed to quick wingers.
The five changes made for the Middlesbrough game were inevitable at the end of a three-game week, but there have been other interrogation points – discipline, for one.
The club was fined £15,000 in response to their behaviour against Sunderland, a fine made heavier by what an independent regulatory commission called an “appalling” and “dreadful” record for failing to control their players. It is hurting them not just in the pocket but on the pitch too; only Preston and Burnley are conceding more fouls.
Luton’s 2024-25 summer window
Ins
- Mark McGuinness – £10m from Cardiff
- Lamine Fanne – £3.7m from AIK (loaned back, to join on 1 January 2025)
- Tom Krauss – loan from Mainz
- Reuell Walters – free transfer from Arsenal
- Shandon Baptiste – free transfer from Brentford
- Liam Walsh – free transfer from Swansea
- Victor Moses – free agent
Outs
- Chiedozie Ogbene – £8m to Ipswich Town
- Ross Barkley – £5m to Aston Villa
- Ryan Giles – £4.5m to Hull City
- Gabriel Osho – free transfer to Auxerre
- Fred Onyedinma – free transfer to Wycombe
- Luke Berry – free transfer to Charlton
- Andros Townsend – undisclosed fee to Antalyaspor
- John McAtee – undisclosed fee to Bolton
- Alan Campbell – loan to Charlton
- Jack Walton – loan to Dundee United
- Dion Pereira – loan to Dagenham & Redbridge
- Aribim Pepple – loan to Southend United
- Dan Potts – released
- Admiral Muskwe – released
- Louie Watson – released
- Elliot Thorpe – released
Edwards, for his part, is unrelenting. “If we turned up and decided to sit off the opposition,” he said before the 1-0 victory over Cardiff, “I think the fans would come and kill me.”
Maintaining that intensity has not been easy; a two-goal half-time lead against Coventry City turned into a 91st-minute 3-2 defeat. Too often they have talked the talk of possession football but in reality that has amounted to little more than playing for set pieces.
“I still think he’s a good manager, I still think he can do a job here but there’s two sides to it,” Harper says.
“Firstly, has the job run its course for him? If it has, it’s the best thing for both parties to go their separate ways. However if he still has motivation, if he still has energy, desire to do the job and motivate the players and get us out of this hole, then I still think he’s the best person for the job.
“I look at the candidates that are being bandied around for the Coventry job, there isn’t really anyone that’s standing out or making me think the grass is greener on the other side.
“If everything of the last 10 months – right the way back to the Tom Lockyer incident– if all of that has suddenly got too much for him, I would have no problems whatsoever if he said ‘look, this is the right time to walk away’ and he would leave with all of our blessing and thanks for two incredible years.”
Where Luton go from here is not entirely clear. Mark Robins is available post-Coventry, though the most natural option is another manager in the mould of Edwards and Joneses Graeme and Nathan. In fact that is the only personnel that is easy to change.
Parachute payments are offset by the Championship’s strict Profitability and Sustainability (P&S) rules, with clubs not permitted to lose more than £41.5m over a three-year period.
The winter window is not expected to be a busy one, not least, Harper admits, because “Luton are ultimately still a small fish in a pond that’s probably still too big for us”. The scars of the financial turmoil that saw them plummet to National League, following the FA’s heavy-handed treatment, are never out of mind. This is a club determined never to veer too close to the knuckle again. The loan market is more likely to yield fruit, Marvellous Nakamba and Cody Drameh respectable coups in recent windows.
But this weekend’s Hull City fixture is already being dubbed “El Sackico”, a who-will-blink-first with both Edwards and Tim Walter on the brink. January and all the promise of a new year may come too late.
from Football - inews.co.uk https://ift.tt/bRL54TU