Five strikers Arsenal should sign instead of Isak, according to transfer experts
The January transfer window has been eerily quiet so far, but Arsenal are one Premier League club that are intent on strengthening their squad.
A 2-1 win over Tottenham Hotspur in the north London derby has galvanised the Gunners’ season after a couple of disappointing cup results, but Declan Rice’s comments that they “could have scored 10” was an admission that they were not clinical with their chances.
This has defined Arsenal’s start to 2025, the 3-1 win over Brentford on New Year’s Day aside. A return of one goal from 49 shots in defeats to Newcastle United and Manchester United emphasised their lack of potency in the penalty area.
Injuries have been a factor with Bukayo Saka sidelined until March or April after tearing his hamstring and Gabriel Jesus out even longer with an ACL tear. The prodigious Ethan Nwaneri has also been unavailable after tweaking his hamstring at Brighton earlier this month.
Earlier this week, Mikel Arteta admitted that it would be “naive” not to be open to bringing a player in this month, even if January is a notoriously difficult window to operate in.
“My answer remains the same,” he said when asked about Arsenal’s transfer plans.
“We are actively looking in the market to improve the squad and that has been since day one.”
Ideally, Arsenal could benefit from adding two attackers to their squad in this window: a wide forward to fill in for and latterly provide competition to Saka and a new No 9 to challenge Kai Havertz, who has faced criticism for his erratic finishing.
However, the second need is more pressing and has been for arguably the last three transfer windows. While both excellent players, neither Havertz nor Jesus have ever scored more than 14 Premier League goals in a single season and fans have long had doubts over the pair’s ability to spearhead a title-winning team.
Alexander Isak’s performance at the Emirates during Newcastle’s 2-0 win in the Carabao Cup semi-final 10 days ago perfectly demonstrated what Arsenal have been missing in attack.
The Swede was sensational with and without the ball, inside the penalty area and outside. He scored Newcastle’s first, fired off the shot that led to their second and made William Saliba and Gabriel Magalhaes look unusually flustered with his pace, strength and movement.
The irony for Arsenal is that Isak has long been a player of interest, even pre-dating his time at Newcastle when he was at Real Sociedad.
Newcastle will not countenance a sale for Isak at the moment given they have propelled themselves into top-four contention, meaning Arsenal may have to look for alternatives instead.
Benjamin Sesko, the towering RB Leipzig striker, has also been on Arsenal’s radar for some time but it may also be tricky buying him this month.
Five forwards Arsenal could sign
So who could Arsenal realistically recruit this month? The i Paper enlisted the expertise of Alex Stewart of Analytics FC – a data-driven football consultancy firm that works with numerous top clubs across Europe to identify transfer targets – to find strikers who match Isak’s profile.
Using Analytics FC’s scouting platform TransferLab, which harnesses a cutting edge algorithm to assess every player action, he found the following players with a profile similar to Newcastle’s main man.
Hugo Ekitike (Eintracht Frankfurt, 22)
A player who could have been a teammate of Isak’s at St James’ Park had he made different choices. Hugo Ekitike was a big target for Newcastle in 2022, but opted to join Paris Saint-Germain instead.
Although that move didn’t work out, the talented Frenchman has got his career back on track in the Bundesliga with Eintracht Frankfurt where he has scored 16 goals in 41 games, including eight in 16 Bundesliga games this season.
“Eintracht Frankfurt’s Huge Ekitike is less strong in the air but offers the same running threat and excellent finishing numbers, as well as good shot numbers. He’s physically imposing too,” says Stewart.
A potential stumbling block could be that Ekitike’s strike partner Omar Marmoush is set to leave Frankfurt to join Manchester City and they may not sanction the departure of two key forwards in one window.
Market value: £33m
Victor Osimhen (Napoli, on loan at Galatasaray, 26)
One of the most sought-after forwards in Europe needs little introduction and he is the type of high-profile signing that would excite Arsenal supporters.
Currently on loan at Galatasaray where he has netted 13 times in 17 games, Victor Osimhen could be available this month with Napoli eager to get his wages off the books more permanently.
“Victor Osimhen remains one of Europe’s elite strikers, despite ending up on loan in Turkey with Galatasary; should Napoli be open to a transfer he would offer exceptional quality in almost every department.”
Market value: £63m
Jonathan Burkardt (Mainz 05, 24)
Jonathan Burkardt has enjoyed an explosive first half of the season, scoring 12 goals in 16 Bundesliga matches for Mainz. Only Harry Kane (16) and Marmoush (15) can better that tally.
“For pure goal threat, Mainz’s Jonathan Burkhardt brings the third best goals per 90 in the Bundesliga [only Patrik Schick and Kane are better]. His link-up play is not quite as strong but he contributes very well in the air.”
Given Arsenal’s well-documented set-piece threat, that aerial prowess would come in handy. Three of Burkardt’s dozen goals have been headers.
Market value: £21m
Keke Topp (Werder Bremen, 20)
If Arsenal do bring in a forward, they will need them to contribute right away. However, every major club will be monitoring up-and-coming prospects more longer term, which makes Keke Topp a possible target.
“The Gunners probably don’t want a project player, as opposed to someone able to come in and score straight away, but if they are prepared to be a little patient Werder Bremen’s Keke Topp, only 20, is a superb prospect.
“He needs to improve his chance quality and shot location choice, but in every other regard this is a brilliantly well-rounded striker with significant upside.”
Market value: £3m
Julian Carranza (Feyenoord, 24)
Finally, a left-field pick. Julian Carranza has made a reasonable start to his career in Europe in the Eredivisie, but like Topp may not make the immediate impact that Arteta requires.
“Another fun one to consider, maybe on a loan, is Julian Carranza at Feyenoord.
“The 24-year-old only joined in the summer from MLS and has yet to play over 400 minutes, but already has three goals and shows elite contribution for xG, aerial wins, and touches in the box.”
Market value: £5m
from Football - The i Paper https://ift.tt/8s7Lg9A