This is The Score with Daniel Storey, a subscriber-only newsletter from The i Paper. If you’d like to get this direct to your inbox, every single week, you can sign up here.
As you were at the top, as if that even begins to explain the madness at Anfield. Manchester City looked done in the title race, but victory means that they can go three points behind Arsenal before their game in hand the next day.
The bigger shift was at the bottom of the table, because you better believe that Nottingham Forest are bang back in trouble after a rank defensive display at Elland Road probably brings us down to one from two to go down. The other one, West Ham, won at Burnley and are now within sight.
Imagine being told back in August, when Forest beat Brentford at home on the opening day, that Nuno Espirito Santo would relegate Forest but wouldn’t be Forest manager at the time. Yes, I am crying inside…
Here is one piece of analysis on each of the top flight clubs who played this weekend (in reverse table order)…
This weekend’s results
- Leeds 3-1 Nott’m Forest
- Man Utd 2-0 Tottenham
- Arsenal 3-0 Sunderland
- Bournemouth 1-1 Aston Villa
- Burnley 0-2 West Ham
- Fulham 1-2 Everton
- Wolves 1-3 Chelsea
- Newcastle 2-3 Brentford
- Brighton 0-1 Crystal Palace
- Liverpool 1-2 Man City
Patience is required at Wolves
The one benefit of being cast adrift at the bottom is that you can steal a march on second-tier rivals. The arrival of Angel Gomes and Adam Armstrong proved as much. So too did bringing back Pedro Lima from his Porto loan; he came off the bench on Saturday.
But it is going to require some patience from Wolves supporters with a third of the season left. Jorgen Strand Larsen has gone, followed by Jhon Arias and Emmanuel Agbadou. Fer Lopez and Marshall Munetsi have gone out on loan. The fees commanded made complete sense, but it does leave Rob Edwards with very little depth outside of central midfield.
The non-midfield or goalkeeper substitutes against Chelsea were Lima (a 19-year-old right-back), a left-back who almost left in January, another right-back in Jackson Tchatchoua and two teenage academy kids and a wing-back in Rodrigo Gomes who has started 12 league games in two years.
Burnley’s toxic atmosphere is growing
You can make a decent argument – and it is backed up by speaking to supporters – that Burnley would have more fun in the Championship where at least they can win a few games and slowly build a squad to compete in the top flight.
For all the deserved criticism of Scott Parker, the current first team is not fit for purpose. When you take 100 points in the Championship, it is hard to argue for overhauling a squad.
On Saturday, we finally saw widescale toxicity at Turf Moor. They understand that their team was likely to be relegated, particularly after Sunderland started so well. But they expect to see a little fight before their team concedes goals (which they almost always do) and they are asking questions of an ownership that took over with Burnley in the Premier League and have succeeded only in turning them into a yo-yo club at best.
West Ham’s brilliant dual threat
West Ham’s season is turning on Nuno Espirito Santo’s ability to get Jarrod Bowen and Crysencio Summerville on the ball as much as possible, but it is the latter who is – perhaps surprisingly – overshadowing the former. Having scored once since joining the club in August 2024, Summerville now has goals in each of his last five matches.
It is working because Summerville has become a dual-threat winger. The usual characteristics are still there: picking the ball up deep, driving at defenders, putting crosses into the box. But in his last four matches, Summerville has had 25 touches of the ball in the opposition penalty area.
When Bowen gets down the right, Summerville has become a specialist – presumably at the instruction of Nuno – at making late runs into the box that also stops the centre-forward becoming isolated in the penalty area. It might just keep West Ham up.
Nottingham Forest have a defensive crisis
Sean Dyche will come under further pressure after another dreadful away performance out of nowhere; that has been one theme of his Nottingham Forest tenure so far. I think Dyche got the team selection wrong by moving Ola Aina and should have made changes long before Leeds’ third goal.
But there is also a defensive crisis here and it has been caused by Forest’s poor recruitment. They have spent around £300m on new players since June 2024 and, judging by Friday night, their first three reserve defenders are Morato, Zach Abbott and Luca Netz. Which is mad.
West Ham are below Forest in the table and their backup defence is Kyle Walker-Peters, Maximilian Kilman, Axel Disasi and either Malick Diouf or Ollie Scarles. I know which I would rather have and it leaves Forest desperate for their first-choice defence to be fit.
All hail Leeds United’s floodlight kings
Leeds were intense, direct, smart and relentless. They were a team created in Daniel Farke’s new image and Ilia Gruev, the least popular of the manager’s starting XI on Friday, was the game’s best player.
They were also playing at home in the evening, which makes a difference. Under Farke, Leeds have played 21 night matches at Elland Road – they have won 18 of those and drawn the other three. Whatever the doubts about Farke, he has an ability to get his team up and to use the crowd to drag them on.
This is why Leeds will stay up. There is an electric atmosphere at Elland Road and they still have Sunderland, Brentford, Wolves, Burnley and Brighton to play there. I would not be surprised if they won all five.
Romero is no longer reliable for Tottenham
Cristian Romero has been held up as a Tottenham freedom fighter for the manner in which he has called out the club’s hierarchy for their lack of transfer activity. That plays well with a fanbase whose relationship with the owners and board has become deeply toxic.
But, as Kat Lucas wrote on Saturday, Romero’s principal role is as a captain and he is no longer reliable in that role. Tottenham needed discipline and intelligence at Old Trafford; their captain was sent off in the first half, cost Spurs the game and will now miss four crucial matches.
Much to Thomas Frank’s surprise (he admitted that he had no idea about the habit), Romero has now been sent off six times in all competitions since his Tottenham debut, more than any other Premier League player over that period. The captain is supposed to set the tone. Romero does that for all the wrong reasons.
Brighton’s unacceptable performance
If I were a Brighton fan I would be absolutely furious. It is not just that their team is in rotten form and lost to Crystal Palace, supposedly the biggest game of the season, it is that they were so powderpuff on every level. Between Palace’s goal in the 61st minute and full-time, Brighton didn’t even attempt a single shot. That is close to a sacking offence.
The whole team is so hesitant that you want to shake them all into life. The passing in midfield and around their defence is ponderous with no purpose, Bart Verbruggen was too slow to come off his line and close down Ismaila Sarr’s angle while neither of the two forwards offered anything at all. Georginio Rutter played 82 minutes as a link-up roaming No 10 and completed four passes in 82 minutes.
Chief executive Paul Barber used his programme notes to back Fabian Hurzeler, but that does not really wash when they have won one Premier League game since the end of November and are now below supposed crisis club Palace in the table. Brighton cannot afford drift to set in.
Lerma embodies the Palace spirit
There is credit due to both Ismaila Sarr, who loves this fixture, and Dean Henderson for fully embracing the spirit of being made club captain following the departure of Marc Guehi, but I wanted to give special praise to Jefferson Lerma.
Lerma is a central midfielder by trade, forced into a central defensive role partly because his club sold their captain and one of the best central defenders in their history. It is an unappetising challenge and yet Lerma was note perfect against Brighton, surely the game’s best player.
One of Lerma’s weaknesses has been indiscipline – you cannot afford to give away fouls as a centre-back without inviting pressure. But he was fouled more often than he committed them and no player in the match made more clearances, headed clearances or tackles. That is how you set the tone in a big game.
Howe could be in trouble at Newcastle
Until now, any serious pressure on Eddie Howe has been deflected by the suggestion that it was only those who watch their team from home or abroad that are criticising him. That changed on Saturday evening. The boos at St James’ Park at full-time were audible and reflected a growing frustration that this team is drifting badly.
Howe does have credit in the bank, but the new chief executive’s suggestion that everybody at the club backs him fully was, I think, mistimed when he could have chosen not to conduct a radio interview. David Hopkinson has said that Newcastle want to win the Premier League title by 2030; this team currently does not look like one that will even qualify for Europe.
That matters because the summer matters. Players who were lured with the temptation of Champions League football will become uneasy, the recruitment led by Howe will (and should) come under serious scrutiny and the direction of the club itself will be drawn into full focus. Newcastle cannot just assume that everything will be fixed next season under the same manager or risk another drift campaign.
Bournemouth’s new-look attack is mighty exciting
In the final few weeks of Antoine Semenyo at Bournemouth, there were signs that Bournemouth were becoming a touch one-dimensional because Semenyo had so much responsibility for carrying the ball forward that opponents understandably tried to double mark him.
That has all changed now and it makes Bournemouth fascinating over the last third of the season. Rayan drives forward as the ball carrier on the right wing. Amine Adli is more of a regulation winger who will look to get to the byline and cross. Eli Junior Kroupi has licence to roam behind Evanilson, who is getting service from multiple teammates.
There are valid doubts about the strength in depth, but the other exciting thing about this new attack? Adli is 25 but only has 50 top-flight career starts, Evanilson is 26 but has fewer than 120 and the other two are teenagers. If you are going to be mid-table, at least be fresh and exciting.
How Fulham can keep hold of Silva
Unlike Oliver Glasner and (probably) Andoni Iraola, I don’t think we should assume that Marco Silva will leave Fulham this summer. He has done a fine job in squeezing maximum return out of this squad and January offered signs that there will be investment over the summer.
If Silva is to stay, he will want promises on further investment in his defence. Jorge Cuenca cost less than £7m and Saturday proved that he is a willing but not always able deputy to Calvin Bassey. At left-back, Antonee Robinson has attacking threat but is found out defensively and the same is roughly true of Ryan Sessegnon (although he played pretty well against Everton).
At right-back, Timothy Castagne is not at the level required for Silva’s ambition and Kenny Tete, Castagne’s backup, should have come on earlier. Fulham likely need at least three defenders this summer.
In defence of Sunderland
This is probably not a good week to make this point, because Sunderland did compete against the best team in the country and the 3-0 scoreline was not representative of the first hour of the match, when they occasionally passed through midfield and threatened Arsenal.
But the general trend is of Sunderland being unable to establish enough attacking threat in their away games. During their current eight-match winless run away from Stadium of Light (where Sunderland have been exceptional all season), they have scored three goals.
Brian Brobbey is brilliant at holding up the ball, but what Sunderland seem to lack are counter-attacking wingers to get beyond Brobbey and provide service for him. In Regis Le Bris’ defence, that could change when Simon Adingra comes back and Granit Xhaka is there to provide more stability in midfield. Without him, Sunderland are essentially using two players as cover.
Everton’s away form is fair enough
Everton have struggled – as many other clubs did before them – to make themselves feel at home in a new ground. We have heard the old Goodison boo in the Hill Dickinson Stadium and David Moyes has had to deal with grumbles about Everton’s inability to dominate possession and territory at home.
That all pales into insignificance when you consider Everton’s remarkable away record. Aston Villa, Chelsea and Arsenal are the only three clubs in the Premier League with more away points this season and all are within three points of Moyes’ side.
Not only has that kept Everton far away from any pressure, it also alleviates the doubts about the home form while they bed in.
Shout out to Brentford’s Andrews
Mikel Arteta will almost certainly win the award if Arsenal lift the title (and I am not going to get angry about that, obviously), but a shout out to Keith Andrews who continues to make his doubters look very silly indeed.
In the last week, Brentford have won their first ever game at Villa Park and won their first game at St James’ Park in 92 years. Andrews’ strength appears to be an ability to win in different ways and to react in-game to a match turning. That is a characteristic that you usually associate with veterans.
Brentford are now safe from relegation with 13 games left to play. They need 20 points from those 13 games to reach their highest ever top-flight points total and if they reach it they may well finish seventh and qualify for Europe. Do either of those and Andrews would be a deserving manager of the year.
Liverpool witness the complete Szoboszlai show
A wonderful afternoon of football, insane entertainment and a breathless finish, all with Dominik Szoboszlai at its heart. Football is at its best when it matters a lot but also with no incentive for a drawn match; this was that scenario in excelsis.
And this is what we know about Szboszlai:
- 1) He hits an absolute bastard of a free-kick.
- 2) He is often at the heart of everything Liverpool do, whether he is picked at right-back or in central midfield.
- 3) At right-back, he can sometimes struggle to hold a flat defensive line (which is not his fault, he is not a full-back).
- 4) He really should have just let Haaland carry on to score rather than pulling him back, because now he misses a match in a situation where the end result was always going to be the same
- 5) I love so much that he appealed for the Haaland foul, knowing quite well what he had done beforehand.
Chelsea fans should pray Palmer stays fit
There has been a lot of talk in recent weeks about Manchester United’s interest in Cole Palmer, accelerated I think because Palmer did not look like he was having much fun. There was a grumpy goal celebration which also led to over-analysis.
This is just a hunch, but I think Palmer just wanted to get fully fit, playing regular football and leading Chelsea again. He is a young bloke who gets a fair amount of grief and when he is not getting to play because of persistent niggling injuries it gets him down.
Nothing better than another Premier League hat-trick to make Palmer feel a lot more happy with life. In post-match interviews, he reflected on a desire to concentrate on making the most of the last three months of the season. I would have him in my World Cup squad and we should desperately hope that he stays fit now.
The improvement in the ‘other’ Man Utd players is instructive
Obviously Bruno Fernandes and Casemiro have stepped up most impressively during Michael Carrick’s four matches in charge. Obviously the return of Kobbie Mainoo and his immediate excellent work paints Ruben Amorim in a miserable light.
But it is the way in which other players look more comfortable that is most instructive. Harry Maguire has been faultless in all four games. Luke Shaw looks far more comfortable as a regulation left-back. Bryan Mbeumo is getting more touches of the ball in the box and finding pockets of space more regularly.
And Diogo Dalot, who has rightly come in for significant criticism over the last 18 months, finally looks confident as a right-back with a winger in front of him, allowing him to go forward when it makes sense rather than with the responsibility for creating chances from wing-back.
Villa’s Elliott farce is damaging for everyone
Harvey Elliott is having the worst season possible, not wanted by his parent club Liverpool and not wanted by the manager at his loan club Aston Villa. A young man with bags of ability is being forced to take a sabbatical. At Bournemouth on Saturday, Unai Emery named two goalkeepers on his bench but still did not pick Elliott in the squad.
“I know we are damaging him, because we got a deal with Liverpool in the summer and the deal is there,” Emery said after the game. “We are taking the decision responsibly from my side. It can change for him, in case Liverpool take off this clause – if they don’t want to, okay.”
This is a result of the Fifa rule that says players cannot appear for more than two clubs in the same season. But honestly, I do not see the point in not having a case-by-case appeals process over that regulation when the end result is a player having his career damaged due to a situation both of the relevant clubs could do without. Elliott is the only person that loses out here and it is not his fault.
Man City still have a pulse
After Manchester City went 1-0 down at Anfield, the camera panned to Pep Guardiola on the bench, sat back in disbelief and presumably succumbing to the reality of Manchester City missing out on the title for a second successive year. He was right: City were done.
We have had a pop at City for their attacking struggles, second-half performances and collapses after falling behind this season, so it’s only right to give them some respect after they displayed – figuratively – balls of steel to get back into the title race. Liverpool certainly helped with a wonky defensive line and a goalkeeper committing a brainfart, but the point stands.
Personally I am not sure it makes any difference; Arsenal are too in control and City too flawed for it to be a sustainable push. But the Premier League is better when teams are fighting for the prize. Sunday afternoon was magnificent entertainment.
Arsenal’s big issue
After his double on Saturday – and note how often Arsenal’s strikers have scored as substitutes rather than starters this season – Viktor Gyokeres has eight Premier League goals. He has been largely disappointing and struggled as a plug-in-and-play Arsenal centre-forward.
Let’s break down those eight goals: six of them against promoted clubs, one against the team in 17th (Forest) and the other away at Everton in December (which was a penalty). Only the Everton penalty actually made a difference to the result. The others came in 3-0, 4-0, 5-0 and 2-0 wins. Only in the Burnley game did that alter the game situation (draw into lead or deficit into draw).
You might argue that this is no problem at all, given Arsenal’s issues in recent seasons breaking down deep defences; that is entirely fair. But then Arsenal did win all six of their matches against the three promoted clubs last season without Gyokeres.
from Football - The i Paper https://ift.tt/PqXu0zb
How Burnley’s disastrous takeover left £113m debt and missing papers