You will struggle to find a stadium in the UK located in a more picturesque setting than The Rock, home of Dumbarton FC.
Stood imperiously above a single-tiered stand containing just over 2,000 yellow and black seats is Dumbarton Castle, a medieval fortress perched on top of an extinct volcano and nestled cosily into the imposing rockface. At ground level, the pitch sits alongside the banks of the Clyde, a safe enough distance away to prevent too many footballs from escaping into the river.
Dumbarton moved to The Rock, officially named the Marbill Coaches Stadium for sponsorship reasons, in 2000 following the sale of Boghead, which had fallen into disrepair at the back end of their 121-year tenancy.
The relocation has proven to be both a blessing and a curse. The stunning backdrop makes it a perfect spot for Sons supporters and football day trippers to while away a Saturday afternoon, but it has also attracted property developers intent on replacing the stadium with houses with the aim of making millions.
That second part is important because it helps to explain Dumbarton’s current predicament. On 18 November, Scotland’s fifth-oldest club entered administration, triggering an automatic 15-point deduction that saw them tumble to the bottom of the League One table.
Promoted via the League Two play-offs last season, Dumbarton are back to square one on zero points. Inverness Caledonian Thistle are the only reason they are not completely adrift after they were hit with the same penalty for the same offence in October.
Quantuma, the firm overseeing Dumbarton’s administration process, stressed that the nuclear option was taken out of necessity. The scale of Dumbarton’s financial ruin is uncertain, but the problems are serious enough that Police Scotland have launched an investigation into “suspected fraud” at the club.
Documents from Companies House paint a grim picture. Accounts from the latest financial year show that Dumbarton recorded losses of £12,500 per month and that scheduled payments from a contentious £1.8m land sale in 2021 have been missed. The terms and funding of that deal, agreed with More Homes Ltd, have been the source of much conjecture.
“The directors of the club were left with no option other than to appoint administrators, following the non-receipt of significant funds that were owed to the club from the sale of development land in 2021,” Quantuma’s managing director Ian Wright said.
“As administrators, we will be investigating the circumstances surrounding this transaction and other issues affecting the club, but will not be in a position to comment further at this time.”
Whenever a historic club falls into the hands of administrators it causes ripples of shock around the wider footballing community: if it could happen to them, it could happen to us.
In contrast, those who have been paying attention and who follow the Sons home and away have long suspected that this day would come eventually. The element of surprise is reduced when the ambush is already expected.
“The Sons Supporters Trust is saddened but not shocked by today’s developments at Dumbarton Football Club,” the club’s official fan group said.
“For almost twenty years now the controlling interest in the club has resided with parties whose principal aim has been to employ Dumbarton FC as a vehicle to enable housing development on the club’s iconic site at Dumbarton Rock.
“Today’s announcement marks the continued failure of that endeavour.”
Owners Cognitive Capital were at the helm when the ship hit the iceberg, but Dumbarton had been drifting off course long before the group’s takeover in 2021. For the past 16 years, Dumbarton’s custodians, past and present, have tried to separate the club from The Rock.
In 2008, Dumbarton were bought by a St Helens-based company Brabco 736, who began exploring potential sites for a new ground. They proposed to build a new 4,000 seater stadium, double the attendance at The Rock, at Young’s Farm at Dalmoak – situated on a flood plain on the River Leven – in Renton village, West Dunbartonshire.
The proposal was rejected by the local council in 2018, but it was a close-run affair ending 10-9, much to the relief of supporters who worried about the ramifications of moving the club further out of town.
“The main motivation, it became clear, was for investors to be able to profit from the relocation through an associated housing development,” Simon Barrow, a Dumbarton fan and former associate director and press officer at the club, tells i.
“But was a larger ground really needed? Would it even be sustainable? Did the investors have the resources to actually make it work for all concerned? The answer to all three questions proved ‘no’. Until planning permission was finally rejected the issue dogged the club and hampered its development at the Rock.”
“We weren’t happy about it. We thought it would spell the death knell of the club,” David Brownlee, chair of the Sons Supporters Trust, tells i.
With their plans rebuffed, Brabco sold up to Cognitive Capital in 2021. The consortium was led by Henning Kristoffersen, a Norwegian financial services entrepreneur, and outlined grand ambitions for the future which included recruiting promising young players from Scandinavia who could be sold for a profit, establishing Dumbarton as a “stable Championship club” and initiating a “transition to a full-time squad”.
Tellingly, their six-point blueprint also sought to “reignite plans for a new, increased capacity community sports and leisure facility at Young’s Farm, without the residential element that previously caused objection”.
“They soon realised that plan was, pardon the analogy, dead in the water,” Brownlee says.
Undeterred, they turned their attention to building housing directly on the site at The Rock instead, on a plot of land currently used as a car park on match days. Understandably, fans were not exactly enamoured with the idea of a multi-storey new build looming over the pitch. It soon became clear that was a non-starter too, at which point everything started to unravel.
The Cognitive Capital era at Dumbarton was doomed to failure from the start. Concerns over the firm’s resources have mounted with fans hoping the ongoing police investigation will unearth definitive answers to some of their long-held suspicions.
There were practical pitfalls too. For over 100 years, the site at The Rock was owned by the Denny family and used for shipbuilding. The land was formerly a dry dock but neither Brabco nor Cognitive Capital had soil samples collected to determine whether the foundations were suitable for building on. A neat metaphor perhaps for the failure of their ownership.
The apparent hastiness to act first and think later prompted Scottish Labour MP Jackie Baillie to accuse Dumbarton’s guardians of chasing a “get-rich pipe dream”, an obsessive pursuit that has left the club in limbo for much of this century.
Clive Hyman, a director at Cognitive Capital, disputed Baillie’s claim by saying “it is in nobody’s interest that the football club should stagnate”.
The uncertainty has been exacerbated by a lack of clarity and communication from Cognitive Capital, who have been described as “opaque” by the Sons Trust. Some directors appear to have been involved with Dumbarton in one way or another for some time.
“Administration was probably inevitable for a long time,” says Barrow.
The plight of Dumbarton and Inverness has prompted renewed discussions about Scottish football’s ability to regulate itself and ensure that owners who take charge of historic, community clubs have their best interests at heart.
The publication of a report titled Rebuilding Scottish Football, prepared by the Scottish Football Supporters Association [SFSA] which was co-founded by Barrow in 2015, brought the topic to the table.
The report stressed the importance of greater transparency and accountability through independent scrutiny, with Barrow saying that an independent regulator would be “the last stop on the train line” for greater protection of clubs.
However, it remains to be seen whether the Scottish Football Association [SFA] will bend to calls for regulations to be tightened.
Last December, Ian Maxwell, the SFA’s chief executive, dismissed the need for Scottish football to have an independent regulator at a government health, social care and sport committee, claiming that the challenges faced by clubs in Scotland were different to those faced by clubs in England.
“I suspect the Scottish Football Association will be dragged screaming and kicking to agree to an independent regulator,” Barrow says.
“But I definitely think there needs to be some sort of due diligence done when companies want to buy clubs like ours with 152 years of history.”
In the interim, there is a growing appetite from across Scottish football for greater fan involvement at boardroom level. Dumbarton have local directors in place but their influence during the Brabco and Cognitive Capital eras was severely limited.
“In the case of Dumbarton, Inverness Caley and other clubs that may be too near the brink, the solution is specific, local and community-focused,” says Barrow.
“It is about ensuring that football clubs are run as effective small businesses with good community and customer relations at their heart – not as magnates for speculators, chancers and accumulators.
“I think many people looking to take a stake in the game also fail to appreciate that a football club is not a standard commercial business. It has far deeper roots than that in people’s hearts, lives and communities.”
Brownlee adds: “We want a model that A) puts football first and B) has community involvement. I don’t envisage a complete fan takeover, but certainly very close fan involvement.
“We have a small supporter base. We will need private money in there but we want the administrator to be sure that folk interested in buying the club’s motives are for the benefit of the community and not planning to develop the land and make a profit.”
Dumbarton’s story has highlighted Scottish football’s murky underbelly, but the football community’s swift response to help out has proven that the bonds that bound fans and clubs together remain as strong as ever.
The day after meeting the administrators, the Sons Trust set up a GoFundMe campaign to pay player and staff wages and “keep the lights on”.
An initial £50,000 target was reached within a couple of days and a new £100,000 goal was set to “address anticipated funding shortfall for the remainder of the season”. That has currently surpassed the £80,000 mark and the Trust have stated that any surplus funds will be reserved for community benefit initiatives once a takeover has been completed.
“The goodwill towards the club and how this news has been received in the community gives us great confidence that the club will be in a better place when all this is finished, even if we end up being relegated,” Brownlee says.
“The response from supporters of other clubs has been quite humbling, really, the money that they’ve put in. It would be nice to say thank you to supporters of other clubs who have supported us. It has been really heartening and we hope that the police investigation gets to the bottom of what’s happened so no other club gets put in this position.”
Administration is a terrifying prospect but there is cautious optimism that a desperate situation can be a catalyst for much-needed and long-awaited change. Encouragingly, Quantuma are “confident there will be a positive outcome”.
“The club is either going to come out of this in better shape than it was before, or it’s possibly not going to come out of it at all. That’s basically the situation,” Barrow says. “But with the right will and commitment, there’s no reason why we can’t survive, and then flourish again.”
If Dumbarton do pull through it is imperative that supporters are at the heart of their rebirth to ensure that the needs of the football club are put first. Fans like Brownlee, who attended his first game in 1958, and Barrow, who has supported the club for 55 years. The fanbase may be small, but there are plenty of people at home and overseas who care deeply about the club.
Although the uncertainty over the club’s financial position and the involvement of Police Scotland may make Dumbarton a less attractive proposition to potential owners, their fans are hopeful that there will still be sufficient interest from parties with the means and ambition to propel the club upstream after years of treading water.
Through his role with the SFSA, Barrow has been working with a group of people hoping to implement “community-facing ownership”, while Brownlee says that the Sons Trust are aware of interest from prospective consortiums and have been informed by administrators that they will be involved in the sale process.
There will surely be a taker for one of Scotland’s oldest clubs and whoever does come in should heed the desire to remain at The Rock. It is the club’s USP – the elephant on the badge symbolises the shape of The Rock and the castle from above – and has become its home. The drive to uproot it has succeeded only in strengthening the resolve to stay put.
“If you look at any book of iconic football games in the world you’ll find it in there. It’s such a historic site,” says Brownlee.
“We want to work with Historic Scotland so that they can promote Dumbarton Castle, rather than just Stirling and Edinburgh! There’s huge potential.”
“The area was once a powerhouse in Scottish football,” Barrow adds. “Our ground is situated underneath the Rock which hosts one of Scotland’s five historic castles. How could this not be a fantastic asset and brand, handled with care and imagination?”
Perhaps a more community-centred ownership would lead to greater collaboration between the town’s football club and historic landmarks. One idea that has been floated is to use the floodlights from the pitch to light up the castle at night.
“We need a fresh chance, fresh thinking, and a fresh approach to making a football club about football and community working and flourishing together,” says Barrow.
Dumbarton have endured their darkest day, but there is hope and optimism for brighter days at The Rock.
from Football - inews.co.uk https://ift.tt/BWJ21aw
Post a Comment